Slice it nice and thick to top your favorite burger while still on the grill - cover the grill and let it melt - we like our slice of cheddar to be melted but still firm in the center for a toothsome bite. Shelburne Farms cheddar comes in a variety of ages, and we've tasted them all. This two-year old cheddar is our favorite. It has a crumbly texture that turns creamy on the palate, and has fruity flavors with a full, sharp finish. The cheese is made from the raw milk of their grass-fed Brown Swiss cows. Pairs nicely with apple or pear jams.