59 Spruce Street Columbus , OH 43215

Homemade Sauces, Pizzas & Family Style Entrees

Welcome to Pastaria & Sarefino's located inside Downtown North Market. We (Don and Carolyn Ziliak) opened Pastaria in 1993 and we pride ourselves on being a small family-owned business. Our main priority has always been to impress our customers with our 18 homemade sauces, fresh pastas, unique raviolis, and unforgettable homemade entrees. Sarefino's is our New York Style Pizza shop located adjacent to Pastaria. If you want the kind of pizza described by our East Coast Customers as “the best pie in town”, you are at the right spot. Yes – this is the best New York style pizza in Columbus! We hand toss every pizza and serve it pie-shaped by the slice daily. Enjoy our parbaked pizzas fresh out of your oven or take home a pizza kit for a fun family activity.

Don Ziliak & Carolyn Ziliak
Owner
  • Store history
    • Joined Mercato 2020
  • Store hours
    • Monday: closed
    • Tuesday: 10:00am-3:00pm
    • Wednesday: 10:00am-3:00pm
    • Thursday: 10:00am-3:00pm
    • Friday: 10:00am-3:00pm
    • Saturday: closed
    • Sunday: closed
  • Store inventory
    • 48 items available
  • Pricing
    • Order min: $20.00
  • Delivery fees
    • Local delivery available
  • Meghan B. Columbus, OH
     1 week ago
1-1 of 1 review
Shop by department

New Items
All items at Pastaria & Sarefino's

Online Grocery Shopping from

Pastaria & Sarefino's

Homemade Sauces, Pizzas & Family Style Entrees
Welcome to Pastaria & Sarefino's located inside Downtown North Market. We (Don and Carolyn Ziliak) opened Pastaria in 1993 and we pride ourselves on being a small family-owned business. Our main priority has always been to impress our customers with our 18 homemade sauces, fresh pastas, unique raviolis, and unforgettable homemade entrees. Sarefino's is our New York Style Pizza shop located adjacent to Pastaria. If you want the kind of pizza described by our East Coast Customers as “the best pie in town”, you are at the right spot. Yes – this is the best New York style pizza in Columbus! We hand toss every pizza and serve it pie-shaped by the slice daily. Enjoy our parbaked pizzas fresh out of your oven or take home a pizza kit for a fun family activity.
Our food delivery service covers these zip codes
  • 43279
  • 43270
  • 43271
  • 43272
  • 43268
  • 43266
  • 43260
  • 43215
  • 43236
  • 43210
  • 43216
  • 43251
  • 43201
  • 43212
  • 43203
  • 43222
  • 43287
  • 43211
  • 43205
  • 43206
  • 43223
  • 43221
  • 43202
  • 43204
  • 43209
  • 43207
  • 43214
  • 43218
  • 43291
  • 43123
  • 43220
  • 43219
  • 43224
  • 43228
  • 43230
  • 43229
  • 43226
  • 43085
  • 43232
  • 43227
  • 43004
  • 43213
  • 43231
  • 43026
  • 43109
  • 43235
  • 43119
  • 43016
  • 43240
  • 43054
  • 43125
  • 43081
  • 43194
  • 43137
  • 43002
  • 43199
  • 43068
  • 43017
  • 43073
  • 43217
My basket
There's nothing in your shopping basket, but together we can change that!
Shop now!
* Estimated item price. Final price based on weight.
Don't see your favorite shop listed?
Vote for them & win a month of FREE gourmet foods!
We're committed to social & environmental responsibility

We believe that building a strong community is about more than just the bottom line.We strive to make a positive impact in the communities we serve.