Sign In
Olive leaves

Fresh from the source since 1912!

We have more than 100 years of culinary history in New York City. Driven by owner Joe Gurrera’s passion for the freshest and best, our once stand-alone seafood shop (whose first location on Manhattan’s Upper West Side originally occupied just a fraction of the space that it does today) has grown into the ultimate gourmet market. Our family-run business now offers 7 locations throughout New York City, the Hamptons, and Connecticut and we take great pride in offering seafood that is fresh from the fishing boats, prime meats that have been aged in-house for 21 days, a carefully curated selection of fresh produce, chef-prepared dishes, handmade pastries, and an exceptional collection of Citarella-brand products. Combined with Joe’s seafood supplying business Lockwood & Winant; and seafood purveying business Meat Without Feet (which supplies some of New York City’s best chefs and restaurants) we boast the largest presence at the iconic Fulton Fish Market.

Joe Gurrera
Owner
  • Store history
    • Joined Mercato 2020
  • Store hours
    • Monday-Friday: 9:00am-7:00pm
    • Saturday: 9:00am-7:00pm
    • Sunday: 9:00am-7:00pm
  • Store inventory
    • 810 items available
  • Pricing
    • Order min: $25.00
  • Delivery fees
    • Local delivery available
  • AV
    Anita V. New York, NY
     1 day ago
    Quality food from a quality store. I am never disappointed.
  • DS
    Deidre S. New York, NY
     1 day ago
  • AS
    Allan S. New York, NY
     1 day ago
  • Esther F. New York, NY
     1 day ago
  • MA
    Melinda A. New York, NY
     2 days ago
1-5 of 1118 reviews
Shop by department

Featured
New Items
Popular in My Area
All items at Citarella- Upper West Side

Online Grocery Shopping from

Citarella- Upper West Side

Fresh from the source since 1912!
We have more than 100 years of culinary history in New York City. Driven by owner Joe Gurrera’s passion for the freshest and best, our once stand-alone seafood shop (whose first location on Manhattan’s Upper West Side originally occupied just a fraction of the space that it does today) has grown into the ultimate gourmet market. Our family-run business now offers 7 locations throughout New York City, the Hamptons, and Connecticut and we take great pride in offering seafood that is fresh from the fishing boats, prime meats that have been aged in-house for 21 days, a carefully curated selection of fresh produce, chef-prepared dishes, handmade pastries, and an exceptional collection of Citarella-brand products. Combined with Joe’s seafood supplying business Lockwood & Winant; and seafood purveying business Meat Without Feet (which supplies some of New York City’s best chefs and restaurants) we boast the largest presence at the iconic Fulton Fish Market.
Our food delivery service covers these zip codes
  • 10023
  • 10069
  • 10024
  • 10153
  • 10019
  • 10020
  • 10105
  • 10075
  • 10065
  • 10152
  • 10154
  • 10155
  • 10036
  • 10021
  • 10025
  • 10028
  • 10112
  • 10111
  • 10103
  • 10104
  • 10172
  • 10171
  • 10175
  • 10177
  • 10162
  • 10165
  • 10169
  • 10018
  • 10022
  • 10128
  • 10170
  • 10178
  • 10158
  • 10166
  • 10132
  • 10133
  • 10017
  • 10016
  • 10027
  • 10118
  • 10095
  • 10179
  • 10151
  • 10156
  • 10011
  • 10138
  • 10029
  • 10117
  • 10119
  • 10114
  • 10116
  • 10115
  • 10001
  • 10124
  • 10109
  • 10102
  • 10026
  • 10213
  • 10055
  • 10031
  • 10030
  • 10126
  • 10101
  • 10081
  • 10292
  • 10037
  • 10286
  • 10010
  • 10256
  • 10265
  • 10269
  • 10008
  • 10249
  • 10013
  • 10014
  • 10003
  • 10080
  • 10033
  • 10032
  • 10282
  • 10285
  • 10012
  • 10451
  • 10454
  • 10060
  • 10185
  • 10271
  • 11241
  • 10274
  • 11245
  • 10276
  • 10279
  • 10039
  • 10280
  • 10160
  • 10281
  • 10163
  • 10164
  • 10130
  • 10131
  • 10261
  • 10007
  • 10009
  • 10121
  • 10242
  • 10125
  • 10006
  • 10211
  • 10108
  • 11202
  • 10004
  • 10199
  • 10150
  • 10035
  • 10157
  • 10040
  • 10041
  • 10110
  • 10452
  • 10212
  • 10034
  • 10038
  • 10002
  • 10005
  • 10453
  • 10456
  • 10460
  • 10463
  • 10471
  • 11101
  • 11104
  • 11106
  • 10472
  • 10459
  • 11386
  • 10462
  • 11377
  • 11222
  • 11103
  • 10090
  • 10272
  • 10015
  • 10259
  • 10203
  • 11373
  • 11102
  • 11201
  • 10455
  • 10465
  • 10467
  • 10458
  • 10461
  • 11378
  • 11105
  • 11217
  • 10469
  • 11370
  • 11251
  • 11372
  • 11211
  • 11385
  • 11249
  • 11374
  • 11379
  • 11231
  • 11238
  • 11237
  • 11369
  • 11225
  • 11232
  • 11206
  • 11205
  • 11218
  • 11215
  • 10474
  • 10457
  • 11221
  • 11213
  • 11216
  • 11375
  • 10468
  • 11220
  • 11226
  • 11233
  • 11421
  • 11416
  • 11368
  • 10473
  • 11367
  • 11355
  • 11354
  • 11228
  • 11230
  • 11203
  • 11219
  • 11417
  • 11357
  • 11356
  • 11358
  • 10470
  • 11210
  • 10466
  • 11360
  • 11361
  • 11209
  • 10475
  • 11204
  • 11432
  • 11414
  • 11214
  • 11229
  • 11223
  • 11359
  • 10464
  • 11433
  • 11224
  • 11693
My basket
There's nothing in your shopping basket, but together we can change that!
Shop now!
* Estimated item price. Final price based on weight.
We're committed to social & environmental responsibility

We believe that building a strong community is about more than just the bottom line.We strive to make a positive impact in the communities we serve.