Sign In
Olive leaves
75 Ninth Avenue New York, NY 10011

Fat Witch is now available for same day delivery!

Fat Witch Bakery casts a spell inside Chelsea Market with their freshly baked brownies. There’s an enchanting variety of brownies and bars available. Some are wrapped for gift giving and some are unwrapped for immediate eating. They’ll package up gift boxes right before your eyes.

You can always visit us on our website at fatwitch.com

If there is a product that we sell in our store or online on our website that you don't see available here, please let us know.

Allison Benyo
Owner
  • Store history
    • Joined Mercato 2020
  • Store hours
    • Monday: 12:00pm-5:00pm
    • Tuesday: 12:00pm-5:00pm
    • Wednesday: 12:00pm-5:00pm
    • Thursday: 12:00pm-5:00pm
    • Friday: closed
    • Saturday: closed
    • Sunday: closed
  • Store inventory
    • 25 items available
  • Pricing
    • Order min: $10.00
  • Delivery fees
    • Local delivery available
  • Aishling S. New York, NY
     2 months ago
    The delivery person was very nice and helpful and made sure that my friend received the order I sent. Very pleased and thankful.
    • Fat Witch Bakery (Chelsea Market)  2 months ago
      Thank you very much for your order, and the nice review, greatly appreciated
  • MB
    Michele B. New York, NY
     3 months ago
    • Fat Witch Bakery (Chelsea Market)  3 months ago
      Thank you for your order with us at Fat Witch Bakery.
  • Tiberius V. New York, NY
     9 months ago
    • Fat Witch Bakery (Chelsea Market)  9 months ago
      Thank you for your business, and thank you for taking the time to give us the stars, greatly appreciated
  • Joseph W. New York, NY
     9 months ago
    A heavenly brownie
    • Fat Witch Bakery (Chelsea Market)  9 months ago
      We are so very happy you enjoyed. Thank you for your business as well as the review
  • KB
    Kristina B. New York, NY
     9 months ago
    • Fat Witch Bakery (Chelsea Market)  9 months ago
      Thank you for your order and thank you for the stars, greatly appreciated!
1-5 of 6 reviews
Shop by department

New Items
All items at Fat Witch Bakery (Chelsea Market)

Online Grocery Shopping from

Fat Witch Bakery (Chelsea Market)

Fat Witch is now available for same day delivery!
Fat Witch Bakery casts a spell inside Chelsea Market with their freshly baked brownies. There’s an enchanting variety of brownies and bars available. Some are wrapped for gift giving and some are unwrapped for immediate eating. They’ll package up gift boxes right before your eyes.

You can always visit us on our website at fatwitch.com

If there is a product that we sell in our store or online on our website that you don't see available here, please let us know.
Our food delivery service covers these zip codes
  • 10014
  • 10113
  • 10095
  • 10156
  • 10011
  • 10138
  • 10116
  • 10001
  • 10199
  • 10276
  • 10159
  • 10018
  • 10013
  • 10121
  • 10123
  • 10122
  • 10081
  • 10292
  • 10036
  • 10282
  • 10286
  • 10010
  • 10012
  • 10265
  • 10117
  • 10119
  • 10114
  • 10120
  • 10003
  • 10124
  • 10080
  • 10170
  • 10176
  • 10175
  • 10178
  • 10179
  • 10158
  • 10279
  • 10278
  • 10165
  • 10285
  • 10169
  • 10019
  • 10016
  • 10118
  • 10110
  • 10112
  • 10007
  • 10101
  • 10102
  • 10090
  • 10172
  • 10171
  • 10174
  • 10173
  • 10055
  • 10177
  • 10060
  • 10069
  • 10271
  • 10280
  • 10161
  • 10160
  • 10281
  • 10163
  • 10164
  • 10167
  • 10166
  • 10168
  • 10017
  • 10020
  • 10111
  • 10008
  • 10009
  • 10004
  • 10107
  • 10106
  • 10103
  • 10105
  • 10104
  • 10150
  • 10152
  • 10151
  • 10154
  • 10153
  • 10155
  • 10041
  • 10043
  • 10015
  • 10258
  • 10022
  • 10023
  • 10249
  • 10002
  • 10006
  • 10005
  • 10109
  • 10203
  • 10065
  • 10270
  • 10272
  • 10038
  • 11251
  • 10045
  • 10131
  • 10024
  • 10260
  • 10021
  • 10268
  • 11201
  • 10025
  • 10075
  • 11243
  • 11101
  • 10028
  • 11249
  • 10162
  • 11217
  • 11109
  • 11222
  • 10029
  • 10026
  • 10027
  • 10115
  • 10128
  • 11104
  • 11106
  • 11231
  • 11238
  • 11206
  • 11205
  • 10031
  • 10030
  • 11242
  • 10037
  • 11102
  • 11211
  • 10032
  • 10033
  • 10035
  • 10039
  • 10455
  • 11241
  • 10040
  • 10452
  • 10453
  • 11221
  • 11225
  • 11232
  • 11216
  • 11215
  • 11377
  • 11378
  • 11237
  • 11218
  • 11213
  • 10451
  • 10456
  • 11103
  • 10034
  • 11385
  • 11370
  • 11373
  • 11379
  • 11220
  • 11233
  • 11212
  • 10459
  • 10454
  • 11372
  • 11374
  • 11226
  • 11230
  • 11204
  • 11219
  • 11369
  • 11371
  • 11228
  • 11105
  • 11207
  • 11209
  • 10474
  • 11203
  • 11210
  • 11368
  • 11252
  • 11375
  • 11223
  • 11208
  • 11214
  • 11421
  • 11367
  • 11229
  • 11355
  • 11416
  • 11256
  • 11239
  • 10457
  • 11415
  • 11417
  • 11366
  • 11365
  • 11351
  • 11354
  • 11435
  • 10472
  • 10458
  • 10460
  • 10463
  • 10468
  • 11418
  • 11414
  • 11235
  • 10471
  • 10473
  • 11420
  • 10462
  • 11419
  • 10301
  • 11236
  • 07024
  • 11357
  • 11358
  • 11432
  • 11224
  • 11356
  • 10469
  • 10461
  • 10465
  • 11433
  • 11436
  • 10467
  • 10304
  • 11234
  • 10310
  • 07605
  • 11360
  • 11361
  • 10705
  • 10470
  • 11423
  • 11430
  • 10466
  • 11434
  • 11412
  • 11364
  • 10305
  • 10302
  • 07010
  • 07632
  • 07631
  • 10704
  • 11359
  • 07650
  • 10475
  • 11451
  • 11427
  • 07020
  • 11362
  • 10701
  • 11429
  • 11428
  • 10464
  • 11413
  • 10708
  • 11004
  • 10703
  • 11426
  • 11422
  • 10552
  • 11005
My basket
There's nothing in your shopping basket, but together we can change that!
Shop now!
* Estimated item price. Final price based on weight.
We're committed to social & environmental responsibility

We believe that building a strong community is about more than just the bottom line.We strive to make a positive impact in the communities we serve.