4464 Broadview Road Cleveland, OH 44109

Urban seasonal cheese making in Cleveland, Ohio!

Founded in 2016 by Michael Januska. Our company is proud to be part of Old Brooklyn, Cleveland Ohio’s largest neighborhood, along with nearby destinations like the Cleveland Metroparks Zoo, b.a. Sweetie Candy Company & A Christmas Story House. We produce quality seasonal raw milk cheese. Hartzler Family Dairy in Wooster, OH, supplies us with Non-GMO certified milk for our raw milk cheeses from when the cows go out to graze in the spring until the end of the season in Sept/Oct. All of our cheeses are aged for a minimum of 90 days.

Old Brooklyn Mustards began as a cold packed house made condiment at the cheese shop to accompany our cheese boards. As the popularity grew, we began producing a shelf stable product and selling our mustards in the Cleveland area. We are very proud the our Pepped Up Mustard is a 2020 Good Food Awards Finalist.



Michael Januska
Owner
  • Store history
    • Joined Mercato 2020
  • Store hours
    • Monday: closed
    • Tuesday: closed
    • Wednesday: closed
    • Thursday: 11:00am-4:45pm
    • Friday: 11:00am-4:45pm
    • Saturday: 11:00am-4:45pm
    • Sunday: 11:00am-4:45pm
  • Store inventory
    • 62 items available
  • Pricing
    • Order min: $10.00
  • Delivery fees
    • Local delivery available
  • JR
    Jocelyn R.
     4 days ago
  • TK
    Tracie K.
     4 days ago
  • VK
    Vincent K. Cleveland, OH
     1 week ago
  • Andrea Z. Cleveland, OH
     1 week ago
  • CJ
    Crystal J. Berea, OH
     2 weeks ago
1-5 of 53 reviews
Shop by department

Featured
New Items
All items at Old Brooklyn Cheese Company

Online Grocery Shopping from

Old Brooklyn Cheese Company

Urban seasonal cheese making in Cleveland, Ohio!
Founded in 2016 by Michael Januska. Our company is proud to be part of Old Brooklyn, Cleveland Ohio’s largest neighborhood, along with nearby destinations like the Cleveland Metroparks Zoo, b.a. Sweetie Candy Company & A Christmas Story House. We produce quality seasonal raw milk cheese. Hartzler Family Dairy in Wooster, OH, supplies us with Non-GMO certified milk for our raw milk cheeses from when the cows go out to graze in the spring until the end of the season in Sept/Oct. All of our cheeses are aged for a minimum of 90 days.

Old Brooklyn Mustards began as a cold packed house made condiment at the cheese shop to accompany our cheese boards. As the popularity grew, we began producing a shelf stable product and selling our mustards in the Cleveland area. We are very proud the our Pepped Up Mustard is a 2020 Good Food Awards Finalist.

Our food delivery service covers these zip codes
  • 44109
  • 44144
  • 44113
  • 44105
  • 44134
  • 44129
  • 44131
  • 44130
  • 44125
  • 44127
  • 44101
  • 44111
  • 44199
  • 44198
  • 44194
  • 44197
  • 44191
  • 44193
  • 44192
  • 44147
  • 44102
  • 44115
  • 44114
  • 44135
  • 44104
  • 44103
  • 44195
  • 44142
  • 44137
  • 44106
  • 44188
  • 44107
  • 44133
  • 44128
  • 44120
  • 44126
  • 44108
  • 44017
  • 44116
  • 44118
  • 44070
  • 44112
  • 44145
  • 44067
  • 44110
  • 44141
  • 44146
  • 44122
  • 44139
  • 44121
  • 44149
  • 44138
  • 44233
My basket
There's nothing in your shopping basket, but together we can change that!
Shop now!
* Estimated item price. Final price based on weight.
Don't see your favorite shop listed?
Vote for them & win a month of FREE gourmet foods!
We're committed to social & environmental responsibility

We believe that building a strong community is about more than just the bottom line.We strive to make a positive impact in the communities we serve.